 |
|
 |
 |
| Fulton, C., Zuccaro, M., & Dumont, R. (June 2002). Readers' Response to Brent Davis, Dennis Sumara and Rebecca Luce-Kapler, Engaging Minds: Learning and Teaching in a Complex World. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc. 2000. Educational Insights, 7(1). [Available: http://ccfi.educ.ubc.ca/publication/insights/v07n01/readersresponse/engagingminds.html] |  |
|
 |
| |
| |
| |
 |
Response No. 1
Carol Fulton - Teacher educator
Ph.D. Student
Centre for the Study of Curriculum and Instruction
University of British Columbia
Engaging Minds immediately excited me. I wanted to contact all
my colleagues and shout, "This is what we should be using in our
teacher education programs!" This book is not the typical text that
is often written for prospective teachers. Instead of a linear, mechanistic,
objective world view that has informed Euro/American education in the
past, the authors use as the basis for their work a holistic, ecological
perspective of teaching and learning, which they call ecological postmodernism.
This world view has also been called enactivism or complexity science
by researchers working in other disciplines and is a relatively new area
of inquiry that is gaining interest in many natural and social sciences.
This view acknowledges the "complex ways that personal and collective
identity are entangled in historical, cultural, biological, and more-than-human
worlds"(p. 178) and "that learning is coming to be understood
as a participation in the world, a co-evolution of knower and known that
transforms both" (p. 65). The authors show how knowing resides not
in the mind, but in the whole body, and how "all learning becomes
part of a complex ecological dance" (p. 197). Not only do the authors
describe this complexity in a way that is interesting and understandable,
they provide fascinating examples such as learning to ski to illustrate
a theory. They also give an overview of other historical and recent worldviews
and theoretical influences that have contributed to Western histories
and sensibilities. In the "Reading Possibilities" section they
list resources written by some advocates of the various schools of thought.
This is an excellent starting point for those who want read further in
any of these fields.
As much as I love this book, I find its structure can be both frustrating
and delightful. The Table of Contents with the unusual, but thought-provoking
headings poses somewhat of a challenge when looking for topics. The index
is very useful though. I am intrigued, however, with the authors' use
of double-meaning, verb/noun phrases such as "labeling problems",
"connecting thoughts", "reading bodies" or "engaging
minds" in the headings, sub-headings and title to give us a sense
of the multiple meanings and ambiguities of language. That our perceptions
are based on language that is fluid, contextual and evolving, is a theme
that is woven throughout the book. I also appreciated that the authors'
use of language is accessible to most prospective teachers.
The format can also be a bit frustrating for those of us who like to
read a book from cover to cover. I am so easily sidetracked by the many
interesting bits. (Did you know a glass of water might increase intelligence?)
On the other hand, I am delighted that I can open it anywhere and immediately
be drawn into the text. The authors deliberately use a number of strategies
such as insert boxes and side notes to prevent a linear reading and to
emphasize that thinking is not linear.
What I liked best, however, is that this book has no prescriptions. As
most experienced teachers know, "how to" directions for teaching
rarely work. Rather, the examples the authors provide, help us to imagine
how we might address various issues within our own contexts. Difficult
topics including assessment and evaluation, classroom management, diversity,
gender and spirituality - issues that can perplex even the most experienced
teachers - are addressed sensitively through an interweaving of current
educational thought and stories. Instead of telling us how to accommodate
difference in the regular classroom, the authors show through narratives
how we might structure tasks that learners can adapt to their own talents
and interests. Folding paper to understand fractions is just one example
of such a task. Instead of telling us how to sensitively handle issues
of diversity as in the case of children who have parents of the same gender
or other family structures, they relate how one student teacher came to
terms with this issue. They show how multiple lenses can be used to interpret
experiences, as in using photographs to imagine the lives of the subjects
in them or creating stories around other people's shoes. Stories such
as these interrupt our taken-for-granted assumptions and provide other
ways of seeing. The paradigm shift represented in this book has possibilities
for transforming how we make sense of our world. I believe this is necessary
if we are to live in harmony with it and with each other.
This book is transforming the way I think. I bought the book.
|
 |
| About the Author |
| |
Carol Fulton is a Ph.D. student at the Centre for the Study of
Curriculum and Instruction, Faculty of Education, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, B.C., Canada V6T 1Z4.
- Teacher - K, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 and alternate education - grades 7-12
- Teacher educator, University of Regina - professional studies,
cross-cultural education, early childhood education
- ESL tutor
- Mother of 3 adult sons
- Research interests include complexity science (enactivism), indigenous
education, community schools
- Recreation interests include, walking, hiking, camping, canoeing,
skiing, dancing and reading.
|
| |
 |
 |
 |
Response No. 2
Meg Zuccaro - Mother
Graduate Student
Faculty of Education
Simon Fraser University
Prepared for a long journey home on a flight from Toronto, I pulled out
my paper and pen, in anticipation of skimming through the pages of this
book, jotting down helpful hints, and ideas to use with my children. I
started to write, and write and write. Within the first half an hour I
realized that this was no way to interact with this book.
Offering a wealth of ideas, this book weaves together theories and practices
on learning, pedagogy, education and parenting, rejecting the notion that
theory and practice can be separated. It is not a 'how to' book offering
step-by-step formulas for checklist teaching. Rich in images, symbols
and metaphors this text is more of a resource than a book to be read cover
to cover. This is one of its many attractions. It is a book to be carried
with you, to rest on your desk, or to sit on your bedside table. Open
it at any page and you can dive straight in.
Organized into five chapters, each chapter is divided into three sections.
'Working Ideas' are supported by "Telling Experiences' followed by
"Interpreting Events' where you will find specific suggestions for
teaching. These suggestions can be used by both teacher and parent, in
or out of the classroom.
The act of teaching is an awakening of our children and ourselves to
the wonders of the world. What happens when we:
- Create stories using other people's shoes as a prompt and discover
the connection between creating human identities and storying?
- Explore 'wild mind' writing exercises, using a piece of hair,
a box of buttons, or a scent in the autumn air as a prompt?
- Pretend to be an android programmer imputing the information
that is required for the android to perform what we do in a day, and we
discover the multiple layers of knowledge, many of which remain unrecognized?
In a continuous conversation the text provides space for opening up dialogue
and opening our awareness of the complex webs of knowledge that are embedded
deeply in our history of human understanding.
Initially, I had a moment of being overwhelmed by the wealth of information
available to me as a reader. Where to begin? I found myself jumping from
one place to another in an attempt to 'get it all.' I then started to
focus on the narratives, which drew me into the world of story and I started
to see connecting patterns between the narrative forms and the more standard
academic prose. Engaged in its web of thought-provoking information, I
connected to the words as a mother, a student and teacher, focusing on
how I can remain present to uncovering, rediscovering and understanding
the layers of meanings in the world through story, writing and conversation.
I bought the book!
|
 |
| About the Author |
| |
I am a graduate student at Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, B.C., Canada. My work involves
the practice of listening from an embodied perspective, weaving
together contemplative traditions, phenomenology and women's autobiographical
writing. My three teenagers have graciously taught me much about
the art of listening.
|
| |
 |
 |
 |
Response No. 3
Ruth Du Mont - Teacher
Graduate Student
Centre for the Study of Curriculum and Instruction
University of British Columbia
Before you continue, I bought the book but,
why should you?
The challenge is to find a way to describe a book
unlike any I have read before. Engaging Minds is motivational,
inspirational and educational. Relevant. Accessible! I see my children,
both at school and at home, in a new light. As I read, I am astonished
at how much I don't know about learning and the processes involved. The
book contains vast amounts of information regarding perception, cognition,
ability, identity and language acquisition: it's akin to discovering elusive
puzzle pieces fifteen years after you started the picture. Eureka!
No matter where the book falls open, something new is revealed. To convince
you, I'll randomly select pages using lottery numbers from my most recent
fortune cookie - 6, 11, 17, 26, 27 and 47. Here goes:
6 - Fig. 1.3 - Human Consciousness:
our sense organs can register in the range of 11 million bits of information
each second....the evidence suggests that humans are powerfully attuned
to and affected by events and circumstances that may never come to conscious.
As teachers, we need to question how children best learn concepts, in
isolation or as part of a bigger picture. Something else to contemplate
is your classroom. What does it look like? What does it sound like? Why
does that matter?
11 - Fig. 1.5 - The [virtually
infinite] Capacities of Human Sense Organs: It is important for teachers
to realize that consciousness is limited, but to consider the conditions
that contribute to what gets noticed. How is a trickle of perceptions
selected out of a torrent of sensorial possibilities? It is naive
to assume that we really know or completely control what kids are truly
getting out of our lessons. Therefore, how do I structure my approach
to best meet the varied needs of so many children?
17 - Fig. 1.9 - What is the meaning
of the symbol / ? "I", "L", "1", "/"
or any number of other things. The meaning is not in the symbol, but in
the complex webs of association that the symbol triggers when it is deployed
in a particular context. Language and symbols never have just one
meaning therefore when we hear or see these icons, a flood of potential
connections fill our minds. I think this might mean that the more associations
we have, the more creative we can be. I think it also means that maybe
we shouldn't be so quick to judge students' answers right or wrong based
on what we think we asked.
26 - Knowing Looks - Teaching seems
to be less about helping students 'know' what they don't know and more
about helping them 'notice' what they haven't noticed. There is then,
no singular 'correct' way of seeing the world. As a teacher, this
dramatically changes my perception of my role. Albert Einstein said, "Learning
is experience. Everything else is just information." How should we
guide?
27 - Seeing Pictures - An anecdote
in teaching: "What do you see?" in the dots scattered
randomly on the page? The beginning activity is an exciting series of
lessons on visual perception.
47 - The realization that humans are
storying creatures is an important one for teachers...the deliberate use
of narrative structures - that is, telling and composing stories to incorporate
new information into established understandings - is an important tool...regardless
of subject area. Most of our memory is stored in story. How can I
use this information to positively impact my students' futures? Coincidentally,
the flip side of that fortune predicts my review: You will bring joy
to many people!
You will en'joy' this book. It has revolutionized the way I think about
thinking, yet, I feel my words inadequately reflect its essence. Maybe
that's what the authors intended: to create something that was potentially
powerful, original and virtually indescribable - just like the precious
lives of Everychild. Maybe in labouring to confine the book to a single
page review, I recognize a comparative incongruity in what we attempt
every day, to pigeon-hole and neatly categorize our multifaceted, amazing
children. Thus, each fascinating page is analogous to the possibilities
within Everychild - a mind with all sensors on alert, all neurons snapping,
every cell significant, individualized in their function but each a contributing
part of the whole. Lives unfolding. Humans becoming. Each a rare and unique
edition.
Why do I care if you read this book? You might be one of my children's
teachers.
|
 |
| About the Author |
| |
Ruth Du Mont is completing her Masters in Education at the University
of British Columbia. She is the mother of two small children and
a teacher in the Burnaby School District.
|
| |
 |
| |
________________ |
| |
Reference
Davis, B., Sumara, D., & Luce-Kapler, R. (2000). Engaging Minds: Learning
and Teaching in a Complex World. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,
Inc. Pp. xv + 282, ISBN 0-8058-3785-X, US$29.00
|
| |
| |
 |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |